Is Homeopathy Quackery?
By Angsuman Chakraborty, Gaea News NetworkSaturday, August 27, 2005
That is the conclusion of a team of medical researchers in Britain and Switzerland, who reviewed a mountain of published evidence. They compared 110 trials of homeopathic remedies against a placebo with 110 trials of conventional medicines, which were also tested against placebos. I beg to differ.
The ailments being treated in these trials included respiratory-tract infections, pollen allergies and asthma, gynaecological and obstetric problems, muscle and joint ache and intestinal upsets.
The researchers found that in small, poor-quality trials both homeopathic and conventional medicines appeared to fare better against placebos or dummy medicines.
But in larger, well-designed trials there was no credible evidence that the homeopathic treatment worked any better than the placebo. Conventional medicines (aka Allopathy) clearly outperformed.
Note: Placebo is normally lookalike pills with nothing more interesting than sugar etc. and with no known medicinal properties. They are administered to neutralize the psychological benefits associated with the patient knowing that he is being treated with a (big) pill. In some patients merely giving them a pill, any pill, improves their health condition. Placebo counters these effects.
Personally I have extensively tried Homeopathy and I have found that it does help in certain diseases while being ineffective in others. For example I would never think of Homeopathy for organ related diseases like kidney or liver problem or even infections. However I have found it to work very well in say constipation or certain stomach ailments, chronic pains etc.
September 4, 2007: 2:31 pm
عذرا على تطفلي ,فلقد قرأت بالصدفه في موقعكم الكريم |
May 28, 2007: 7:00 pm
I was cured from Ashtma with homeopaty, as a child. So at least in my experience, it works, but not for every disease. It doesn’t do anything against the Flu, for instance. |
August 30, 2005: 7:09 am
My wife has an aunt who used homeopathy to treat her breast cancer. While being monitored by a state-licensed physician, she took herbal supplements from her nature doctor. After just under a year of treatments, she’s in remission. It’s hard to say I’m still not a believer in herbal remedies after this, but I’m still a skeptic. |
August 29, 2005: 1:19 am
[...] Michael Heilemann presents an “Ode to Summer”. Brian finds a missing link in the “Google OS” theory. Khaled is hunting for a new mobile phone. Kafkaesquí posts an important message for new WordPress users. Michael Hampton launches Lunacy Unleashed, a blog devoted to his WordPress and Bad Behavior announcements and information. Jon is having great success with GoogleRumors. Craig celebrates his birthday. Chris provides a tutorial for how to create a coffee table art book. Angsuman briefly discusses Homeopathy. And, Mark ruminates on the FCC. [...] |
aljundi