Game Review: ‘Madden NFL 10′ franchise’s best football video game to date

By Dirk Lammers, AP
Thursday, August 13, 2009

Review: ‘Madden NFL 10′ is franchise’s best yet

Football fans have grown accustomed to spending their Sundays in front of gigantic high-def TVs, and they can’t just drop their visual expectations when the game goes virtual.

EA Sports exceeds those expectations with “Madden NFL 10″ ($59.99; Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3; in stores Friday), and the 21-year-old franchise has delivered its most striking, realistic-looking football video game yet.

Athlete and stadium models that looked great last year jump off the screen with improved lighting effects and the addition of depth of field, which blurs out the background to make the foreground appear more vibrant.

Players can customize their team’s game day look using pieces from home, away, alternate and classic uniforms, and the game’s TV-like production is enhanced with varied camera angles between plays and on kickoffs.

Game play doesn’t undergo a drastic overhaul from “09″ — and that’s a good thing — as the developers at EA’s Tiburon studio polished and revamped a ton of on-field animations, especially with tackling.

Running backs fight to stay upright and keep their feet moving to fight for a couple extra yards. Defenders dive low to trip up a receiver trying to eke out extra yards on a cross route.

The game added gang tackles, and up to nine players can push a pile back behind the scrimmage line or toward the first-down marker. Refs even blow a play dead when an upright pile stops forward progress without falling.

A new mini-game adds interactivity to fumbles, letting players mash buttons to fight for the ball in a pileup. This could get annoying if it happened on every loose ball, but it’s used sparingly when appropriate.

Another new feature is the controller will rumble when a rusher nears the quarterback, allowing those with pocket presence to scramble to keep a play alive. And unlike previous “Madden” versions in which the passer was either sacked or got the throw off, a clutched quarterback can inadvertently slam a ball into the ground or toss a lob that’s up for grabs by lumbering linemen.

Reception animations look more realistic, even on replay, and I even pulled off a David Tyree-style helmet catch in the end zone during a brief Super Bowl moment.

EA Sports has long used the “It’s in the game” tag line for its games, and the phrase definitely applies here.

Zebras consult on whether a ball carrier crossed the goal line and will call for the chain gang on questionable first-down conversions. Coaches berate quarterbacks after a careless interception and shake hands and chat with their rivals after the game.

You’ll also hear considerably more player chatter, fan rants and crowd chants.

The game’s incredible online Franchise Mode is back, letting Internet-connected players form leagues, conduct drafts and compete while managing rosters and transactions through a Web browser. A new two-player online co-op mode provides a way for friends to team up.

Frankly, it’s a struggle to come up with criticisms for “Madden NFL 10,” but even the 16-0 New England Patriots lost a Super Bowl — so here are a few.

The computer always seems to be able to pull off a play that I can’t do, but maybe it’s my lack of talent since I’ve been whining about that since “Madden NFL 94.” And there’ll always be that occasional weird animation, such as a 360-degree arm movement that surely should have brought out the injury cart.

What else? Well, those sideline photographers wearing the red NFL vests don’t follow the ball carrier with their lenses.

The attention to detail in “Madden NFL 10″ is astounding, and it’s almost worth giving others the controls for a game or two and just sit back and take in all the visuals.

Four stars.

While EA stepped up the realism for the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 “Madden” versions, it further pushed its Wii version ($49.99) away from a sim into a family friendly arcade game.

After going after the casual gaming crowd last year by adding an optional simplified control scheme, EA further diverged here with a new visual style that puts exaggerated weight-room-happy linemen alongside tall lanky receivers and defensive backs.

As expected, the graphics come nowhere near its big brother, but the game is fast and fun, and the Wii’s motion controls make it more interactive.

Three stars.


On the Net:


October 6, 2009: 9:07 pm

I’ve been playing madden since 2000. My first demo was on a mac.

Anyhoo MAdden 10 ,.. pain in the rear playing w PS3. They sabotaged My game. they changed the controller setup. instead of adding to what they had, they re-wrote the config and assumed you would like it better. Not so.

my game speed was just fine, now why would I want to re learn how to run the ball, or how a quarterback throws the ball. Oh Stiff Arm is not there, holy crap it’s Pitch The Ball !

Play calls and defensive assignments take time to learn. now we have to learn how to play the game again. ~ LAMe graphics rock, controller setup “huge Minus”

And to boot,… CHris Colensworth eeeek.

will not be displayed