10 Reasons Why NOT TO Buy Apple iPhone in India

By Angsuman Chakraborty, Gaea News Network
Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Apple iPhone needs no special introduction anymore. There have been numerous articles and Millions of people who have been fanatic about iPhone - some rationally, some blindly. Here in this article, we are not going to talk about Apple iPhone or anything related to it in a global scale (there is hardly anything left to know about Apple iPhone), but a different aspect and from a specific zone. In India, much to the contrary to the rest of the world, Apple has presented iPhone with strange marketing strategies, extremely overpriced figures and features & technology which didn’t impress the population of  more than 1.2 Billion people. What are the main reasons for not buying the Apple iPhone in India? Let me put them up for you.

1. The Cost Factor: 4 Times More than the Original Price

When Apple iPhone was launched in the US for $199 with all the hypes and excitement, I couldn’t wait to buy one and waited like hell for it to come to India asap. The Indian Price would have been somewhere close to 9000 if converted from Dollars. What followed was a sure shock. The Apple iPhone was priced at 32,000 INR, almost 4 times more. I didn’t know why, nor was I interested. Rs 32K for even a piece of Apple iphone was just TOO MUCH. Period.

2. 3G! What is 3G?

I don’t blame Apple iPhone for this one. There is no point in accusing them for a service which is one of the most important aspects of Apple iPhone. 3G technology is surely the way to connect to future mobile technology and India doesn’t have it YET. Leave apart the other issues, but we Indians have always been very naive about adopting to technology which can be really fruitful for us to actually globalize resources and knowledge and 3G wasn’t of any exception. 3G gets further delayed according to a recent article and from an Indian point of view, there is no point in visiting Darjeeling when you can not see the sunrise from Kanchenjunga .

3. Support of Message Service

This has been discussed a zillion times and still for any discussion on iPhone, it will come again. The SMS service doesn’t have any forward option. I donno about others but people forward a huge number of SMSes to each other, esp Indians. Not to have it is to kill the sense. Period.

There isn’t any MMS feature. I mean com’on. You can not send an MMS to a friend in special occasions, a nice song or a wonderful video despite claiming to have most sophisticated phone of the world.

4. No A2DP Service

There is no intent to deglorify India when I say that India has one of the busiest traffics with overwhelming population in the world. These are facts. And if you are a busy mobile talker, then not having a stereo headset bluetooth service (A2DP) in busy streets is something which you will not want. To put it in another way, you will spend 30 odd thousand Rs on a phone and wish that you don’t need to search your pocket each time someone calls you up.

5. Camera? - Its just Poor

There is nothing Indian about it. Even though it came at the late stage of 2007, Apple iPhone could do with a bit more than 2 MP camera. The clarity is quite good, there is no doubt. But with 10K or more one can have a phone with at least 3MP camera. To add to it, there is no AutoFocus, flash (without a hack) or zooming options in the camera.

There is no frontal camera either for Apple iPhone. So any chance being a tech savvy professional who can have a video conferencing while at home or on road, is out of question.

6. No Copy and Paste

Half the world of information exchanged in internet or through other digital media are initiated from CTRL+C and CTRL+V. Yes, copy and paste. Unfortunately, you don’t have anything like this in Apple iPhone. Don’t ask me why didn’t they include the kohinoor when they were talking about diamonds (Lol, I know I am exaggerating) but still, it is something which I can not simply overlook.

7. GPS - How Effective is it in India?

Well, GPS navigation is another important feature of Apple iPhone. There have been a number of very useful apps to support that feature of iPhone. But, the GPS is simply not effective in India. Another point where Apple has nothing to care about but being an Indian, this point is totally relevant for us, no? GPS Maps will only show ur location and will not provide you turn by turn navgation to an area. To be very true, India has so many lanes and by-lanes and mazes and alleys that to acquire a precision in GPS is very hard. We don’t get it from Apple either. So bunk it.

8. Contact List Portability - Zero

You are a popular person or you love to make friends. You have lots and lots of numbers and multiple SIM cards too. One may wish to save contacts for different people to different SIM cards. Its understandable and is quite a sought after feature too. Nokia has it, Sony Ericsson has it, I mean everyone else has it but Apple. You can not just import contact list to SIM card from phone. No forwarding, no importing.

9. Stuck with a Single Service Provider

We live in democracy right? So why is this kind of ridiculous strategy adapted by Apple that whenever we need to buy an Apple iPhone, we will have to buy it as a joint package from Vodafone or Airtel. Why can’t I chose my own? Again, the data plans for Apple iPhone are too much for any user. A low cost plan with Rs 0.60/minute (which is still thrice more than the normally cheapest Vodafone call charge) will cost you 799Rs/ Month. Why will I need that expensive plan?

10. Comparison and VFM Analysis

Considering all the 9 points discussed above and the price which is so reasonable by all means, I don’t think I can call this one a value for money product in India. Can you? Again, I can get a good cellphone which may not look the way Apple does to be very honest but satisfies most of the features that Apple can not and some more. For an e.g. Nokia N81 is not much of a popular product from Nokia’s N-series gallery, but still works decently fine and has all the features which can make you feel like a happy owner of a good modern day mobile phone. The best part is, it will save more than Rs 10000 from your pocket.

Conclusion

Apple may be a great product, I don’t deny that by any means. But Apple iPhone has two things going against it at this moment in India particularly.

1. It has some notable features missing in itself which makes me least interested to buy it with a price which can bring me the best of mobile phones from other manufacturers.

2. India isn’t even ready to put some of Apple iPhone’s advanced features into effect such as 3G, GPS navigation and etc discussed above and that is not Apple’s mistake by any means.

So, taking all these into account, an once-so-excited soul about Apple iPhone heaves a sigh and signs off.

Discussion
March 26, 2010: 4:27 am

The greatest ‘foolishness’ about Apple iphone is ’stuck with one service provider’. It seems that Steve Jobs really meant ’stay foolish’.


Yemkey
February 8, 2010: 3:03 am

Apple iPhone is not connectable with other brands via bluetooth
battery life is very short when u browse especially
maybe next upgradation will solve it

November 25, 2009: 2:48 am

First point is worthless. The Cost Factor: 4 Times More than the Original Price.
As the price they charge there in USA or other countries are connection with the mobile service provider. Generally that comes free with conn. provider. For high end phone they charge little bit.

March 8, 2009: 2:18 pm

Angsuman,

Jeez man… you are one of those people who simply wont accept the facts. I repeat, the $199 ‘promise’ was only for the initial 22 countries. Dont believe me? Check out the key not your self: https://www.apple.com/quicktime/qtv/wwdc08/
Well… so much for the promise you keep on about.

“then launch it by breaking their promise of a cheap but high quality phone.”

Seriously man. You really have a knack of blaming people for things you ‘EXPECTED’ them to do!!

Well I give up. Remember, shouting louder does not automatically make you right.

Oh by the way…. after 4 months I can say that the iPhone remains the best phone I have used till date.

All the best with your Nokia 1200.

January 23, 2009: 1:18 am

Bobby,

Get your facts straight. Steve Jobs promised iPhone for $199 and the list of countries included India. The 22 countries and the 70 countries distinction applied only for availability on July 1st or later, not to the price.

> Thank Apple that they gave us a choice of two providers, in most countries it is just one.

I am so honored; and they each charge the freaking high price of Rs. 32000, get a life dude and stop sucking up to Apple! That’s the choice between frying pan and fire.

> I agree that the pricing is ridiculous but that’s more or less the price you pay anywhere else in the world if you have to buy the phone out of contract.

In India, too you have a contract for two years. Again, check your facts.

> I am the proud owner of an iPhone..

No wonder you are sucking up to Apple, but hey have some pride in your self, the sound you are making is too loud.

> I mean you really dont need a blogger…

But you need a blogger to tell Apple how they have ashamed themselves by going back on their promise. They can be a great company in US. For India, they are just yet another wannabe’s who failed to show respect to merely 1.2 billion Indian customers. Don’t you think promises are meant to be kept. Customers don’t care about Apple’s deal with careers. I would rather that they didn’t launch it in India, then launch it by breaking their promise of a cheap but high quality phone.

btw: Can you tell me how many Apple stores are there in Kolkata?

January 23, 2009: 12:57 am

@ Yura

You are absolutely right. The thing is I do not say Apple iPhone is a bad product. It is really outstanding. But, the marketing strategies were not impartial to say it mildly.

Regards,

Soumya Sinha,

Simple Thoughts

January 23, 2009: 12:53 am

@ Bobby,

First of all thank you so much for taking the pain and posting such a detailed introspection which is enlightening to say the least. I will really like to agree with you in most of the cases, but differ in some.

“Most of the deficiencies of the phone can be mitigated by a visit to the App store”

Its really commendable. But, as you said, quality has a price. And all the essentially useful apps have a price there. Why will I spend more money for basic features in a phone which I have bought already?


“Most blogs on the iPhone by Indian writers are highly subjective.

I didn’t know that Mathematics don’t talk of objectivity!
“Quality has a price.”

You have me covered here. Its true. I never denied Apple iPhone the appreciation it deserves being an outstanding product itself. But the context is iPhone in India. and its just too heavy a price for a phone of even iPhone’e stature. Period.

Regards,

Soumya Sinha
Simple Thoughts

January 22, 2009: 11:21 pm

Let me clear up some inconvenient truth that the article states.
The $199 rate that Jobs announced at Macworld applied to only 22 countries and India was NOT in that list. It was in the extended list of countries in which the iPhone would be available last year. Period.

Moreover, those 22 countries got the phones at 199$ not because Apple was selling it at that rate. It was because of the carrier subsidy.

Most of the deficiencies of the phone can be mitigated by a visit to the App store. Thats whats so cool about the iPhone. Developers rule. The MMS app is an example.

Thank Apple that they gave us a choice of two providers, in most countries it is just one.

I agree that the pricing is ridiculous but that’s more or less the price you pay anywhere else in the world if you have to buy the phone out of contract. Never knew this I guess.

Most blogs on the iPhone by Indian writers are highly subjective. Its just a way for them to vent their disgust over something they cant afford. Articles and reviews IMHO should remain objective. I mean you really dont need a blogger to tell someone that 32000 is a high price for the phone!

I am the proud owner of an iPhone and in spite of its limitations its the best phone I have owned since I have started buying phones, which is not a small number by any means. I have used over 30 phones in the past 6 years of all possible manufactures including Philips, Benq and Ericsson (when they were just Ericsson and not Sony Ericsson)

My previous phone was an 02 atom exec which had all the features you found missing on the iPhone and countless more. But you know what? Its the worst phone I have used in my life.

Quality has a price.

https://codewidgets.blogspot.com/2008/07/impressions-why-iphone-3g-wont-sell-for.html

January 21, 2009: 12:42 pm

I have to say that international attempts to sell iPhone, except for maybe English speaking countries, were not prepared and seem like an attempt to earn easy money at the cost of the customers.

In Russia, we too have to pay about $1000 for an iPhone, which seems to be even more, than the price in India.

YOUR VIEW POINT
NAME : (REQUIRED)
MAIL : (REQUIRED)
will not be displayed
WEBSITE : (OPTIONAL)
YOUR
COMMENT :